The ultimate property management vendor guide: How to build, audit, and manage a reliable network

Managing property maintenance effectively takes more than just having a list of vendors at the ready. It means knowing exactly who to assign to a project to get the best price for the fastest, highest-quality work.

Having the right vendor for the job means faster repairs, cost-effective service, happier tenants, and a boost to your company’s reputation. On the other hand, putting the wrong vendor on a project, or even engaging in the wrong types of vendor relationships, can damage your business permanently.

We’ve put together this guide to help property and community managers manage, audit, and renegotiate vendor relationships to get the most value out of maintenance and repair services.

Keep reading to learn the strategies and tools you can use to cut costs without compromising on service quality or wasting time on inefficient vendor management.

How to Manage Your Existing Property Management Vendor Network

Once you’ve built up a network of reliable vendors, you’ll need a way to  manage them effectively and track their performance. Here are some suggestions.

Create Detailed Vendor Profiles

When you’re dealing with multiple vendors on a regular basis, it’s important to stay organized. It’s a good idea to invest in software that allows you to keep all of your vendor proposals and contracts in one place. In a perfect world, the same system will also coordinate with your accounting software to facilitate a seamless payment process.

Steps to take:

• Invest in the right property management software: Choose a software that allows you to create separate profiles for each vendor you hire. This capability lets you sort  your records, invoices, and communication associated with each vendor  and stay on top of payments.
• Upload all of your existing documentation: While it may feel like a challenge to digitize your existing vendor records, doing so will help streamline the vendor management process going forward. Effective property management software should allow you to upload and organize documentation for different vendors easily.
• Update your records regularly: Make sure you update the system every time you hire a vendor, bring them back for a job, or let one go. Keeping your records up to date can help avoid confusion and clarify misunderstandings.

Tools to help:

• Property management software: Using a property management software that comes with built-in vendor profiles, such as Buildium, can help you organize all of your vendor records and automate your payment workflow.

Keep a Record of Work Orders

With your vendor profiles set up, it’s time to apply the same level of organization to your individual work orders. From the initial request to the final payment, you’ll want an efficient way to track the progress of each work order and share updates as you go. In addition to simply making note of the work that was done and who completed it, you should keep tabs on details such as how long it takes to complete each stage, vendor response time, and the historical cost of repairs.

This full picture gives you a better understanding of how effective each vendor is for different types of jobs and equips you with hard evidence to negotiate future vendor contracts, as well as convey your value to clients. You can also see exactly what vendors charged for a project, how long it took to complete it, and how well the work holds up over time (i.e. were  additional repairs or follow-up work required earlier than expected).

While this may take some additional effort, maintaining in-depth records is the key to recognizing recurring repairs as they crop up and making informed decisions on how to handle them going forward. To make this easier, look for software that integrates with your vendor records, payments, and resident communication (or, better yet, is built into a comprehensive platform, such as Buildium). This makes it possible to reference work orders in real time, set up automatic updates when a step is completed, and analyze all your past work orders to monitor vendor performance.

Want to learn more about how to properly manage maintenance requests? Our guide on how to manage rental property maintenance projects can help.

Steps to take:

• Find the best tracking system: Identify a system that allows your residents to submit work orders for all of your available maintenance services and lets you track vendor performance metrics.
• Carefully catalog all work orders: Stay on top of keeping your work order tracking system up to date, so that you have the information you need.

Tools to help:

• Maintenance request tracking: Utilizing software that allows you to manage maintenance requests easily will make tracking work orders and identifying recurring repairs much easier.
• Maintenance response automation: Buildium’s marketplace partner, Property Meld, can help you respond to maintenance requests automatically and even troubleshoot them before calling a vendor.
• 24/7 customer support solution: Buildium’s maintenance contact center provides access to call center agents who can field incoming maintenance requests and determine if they qualify as an emergency.

Collect Feedback on Vendor Work

While it’s important for property and community managers to be satisfied with a vendor’s work, it’s also important to gather feedback from any tenants, homeowners, or board members involved in the project. Taking this extra step can help you gain insight into aspects of the vendor’s work that you would not normally get to oversee—while demonstrating to stakeholders that you’re prioritizing their experience. This feedback can help guide decisions on which vendors should remain at the top of your list and which should be let go.

Steps to take:

• Send out regular surveys: Surveys are a great way to gather feedback from a large number or residents at once. Send them out regularly through your resident portal to receive up-to-date opinions on the vendors in your service pool.
• Utilize other forms of resident communication: Since not all residents will complete the surveys, consider using alternative forms of communication, such as email or phone calls, to gather resident feedback, as well.
• Keep track of the feedback: Don’t let the feedback you’ve gathered fall by the wayside. Do your best to keep detailed records for later use.

Tools to help:

• Feedback automation: Buildium’s marketplace partner, Opiniion, can help you automate the feedback-gathering process by automatically sending out surveys and prompting online reviews.

Cut Costs by Conducting Regular Property Management Vendor Audits

Now, it’s time to put all the data you’ve collected in the steps above to good use by conducting a vendor audit. Regular auditing helps you cut costs by helping you to eliminate inefficiencies and optimize your operations. While audits work best when done on a quarterly basis, you should be sure to at least perform one each year for every vendor in your network.

Steps to take:

• Analyze vendor transactions: Take a hard look at each work order completed by the vendor and look for patterns, such as incomplete fixes or recurring repairs.
• Review resident feedback: Consider the feedback you’ve received on the vendor and whether the majority of it is positive or negative.
• Re-interview the vendors: Ask the vendor about any potential problems you’ve uncovered during your analysis to get their perspective on those issues.
• Re-read your contracts: Take a look at exit clauses and pricing information so that you can get a sense of the best way to move forward.

Tools to help:

• Up-to-date analytics: Buildium’s analytics and insights make it easy to gather the reporting you need for conducting regular vendor audits.

There’s a lot that goes on in the property management world besides overseeing vendors, check out Buildium’s 2025 Property Management Industry Report to stay on top of the latest industry-specific insights and trends.

Put Your Audit Results into Action

Once you’ve done your audits, the final step in this process is to act on the results. You’ll need to make tough decisions about who gets to stay in your vendor network and be able to renegotiate contracts to make up for any mistakes or oversights.

Steps to take:

• Decide who to keep: Weigh the results of your audit and decide which contractors are worth maintaining relationships with going forward.
• Set expectations: Have another conversation with each vendor to discuss the results of the audit and whether you intend to continue using their services in the future. If any changes are needed on their part in order to continue working together, be sure to make your expectations very clear.
• Renegotiate: If necessary, negotiate contracts and pricing to reflect the vendor experience you’ve had so far. We’ll explore this in the next section.
• Find new vendors: Source new vendors to replace any previous ones that weren’t up to your standards.

Tools to help:

• E-signature software: Buildium’s partner, DropBox Sign, lets you handle lease and vendor contract negotiations electronically. Instead of redlining and signing contracts by hand, do it digitally in a fraction of the time.

How to Renegotiate Vendor Contracts

Renegotiating vendor contracts can be a delicate process. However, it’s essential if you want to improve the level of service you’re receiving and eliminate the costs that come with inefficient maintenance management. Here’s how to go about conducting these conversations the right way:

Steps to take:

• Come up with a game plan: Before you enter into the conversation, decide what your ideal end result will look like. Whether you want additional assurances built into the contract, an expansion of service, or discounted services, make sure you have a plan for a resolve.
• Gather your evidence: Gather evidence of your vendor’s performance. The records stored in your maintenance and property management software is usually the best place to start.
• Communicate clearly and respectfully: You’re going to want to ensure that your vision for the new contract is clearly understood. Use your records to strengthen your side of the negotiations.
• Get everything in writing: Once you’ve reached a verbal agreement, ask the vendor to bring you an updated copy of the contract. Read over it carefully and don’t be afraid to make changes as needed.
• Sign the contract: After any necessary alterations have been made and agreed upon by both parties, sign on the dotted line.

Tools to help:

• Contract tracking software: Ironclad is an AI-infused contract management software tool that includes redlining tracking to simplify contract negotiations. It’s an effective way to save you time and guesswork if combined with the other software we’ve already discussed in this guide.

How to Replace and Screen New Vendors

If contract renegotiations don’t go as well as expected, you may need to replace some vendors in your vendor pool. After all, every property and community manager needs to have a network of reliable vendors that they can call on when needed.

Steps to take:

• Design an RFP:  Your Request for Proposal (RFP) should include a price bid, the criteria on which each potential vendor will be evaluated, roles and responsibilities, and quality expectations.
• Compare the bids: Review the bids once you’ve received them. Keep searching until you’ve compiled a shortlist of qualified candidates.
• Interview and screen each vendor thoroughly: The vendor screening process is the most important stage of all. Make sure you feel confident that you’re deciding on a candidate that aligns well with your larger business goals.
• Negotiate the new contract: Go through the process of negotiating the contract with your new vendor.
• Terminate your old contract: Only terminate your contract with the old vendor once you’re sure that you have a reliable, new vendor in place.

Tools to help:

• Property management business performance software: Industry-specific performance and analytics tools can help you put hard data behind your business goals that you can then use to find vendors that align with your needs.
• Comprehensive spreadsheets: Maintaining a spreadsheet—like this vendor selection scorecard—can help you keep track of your impressions from each interview and the results from your screening process.

How to Fast-Track Effective Property Management Vendor Management

While doing all of the tasks above may take some effort and coordination, this process will be a lot easier if you have a clear and unified property management software system in place. Software systems such as Buildium allow you to create separate vendor profiles, track work orders, and generate the appropriate reporting with the touch of a few buttons.

Get started with a risk-free (no credit card needed) 14-day free trial of Buildium  to put all the tools we mentioned in this article to the test and see how effective streamlined vendor management can be