Putting your rental property on the market can feel like a risk and can raise a lot of questions. Are you marketing your unit to attract the best possible tenants? How do you settle on reliable renters that will respect your property? To address these concerns, you’ll need to set up a solid tenant screening process.
As a landlord, you’ll need a way to spot tenants who will abide by the lease agreement, pay their rent on time, and contribute positively to the rental community—and you’ll need to do it fast if you don’t want your ideal renters to move on to another property. This post explores all the aspects of fast, efficient tenant screening for landlords, plus practical tips to help you find the best tenants for your property.
Why Tenant Screening Is Important
Proper screening helps landlords avoid potential problems by identifying tenants who are likely to be responsible and reliable. It can save landlords time, money, and stress in the long run by minimizing the risk of late payments, property damage, and eviction.
A thorough screening process will help you to find these kinds of tenants and, just as importantly, to do so in a way that is fair to all renters.
Establishing Screening Criteria
The first step in tenant screening for landlords is to establish clear criteria for evaluating prospective tenants. To keep your search consistent, fair, and effective, consider the following factors when developing your screening criteria:
- Income: Prospective tenants should have a stable income that is at least three times the monthly rent. This ratio helps ensure they can afford the rent comfortably.
- Rental History: Checking a tenant’s rental history can provide insight into their behavior as tenants. Look for a history of timely rent payments, proper maintenance of the property, and positive relationships with previous landlords.
- Credit Score: A good credit score indicates a tenant’s financial responsibility. While this shouldn’t be the only factor, it can serve as a valuable indicator.
- Background Check: Conducting a background check helps landlords identify any criminal history or other red flags that could impact the safety and security of the property and community.
- References: Collecting references from previous landlords, employers, or personal contacts can offer additional insights into a tenant’s character and reliability.
Advertising Your Rental Property
Effective advertising attracts a pool of qualified applicants, making the screening process easier. Here are some tips for advertising your rental property:
- Create a compelling listing with detailed descriptions and high-quality photos.
- Highlight key features of the property and the surrounding neighborhood.
- Use multiple platforms to reach a wider audience, including online rental websites, social media, and local newspapers.
Pre-Screening Applicants
Pre-screening helps landlords filter out unqualified applicants early in the process. The following strategies can streamline pre-screening:
- Application Forms: Request prospective tenants to complete an application form that includes basic information such as income, employment, and rental history.
- Initial Interviews: Conduct brief phone or in-person interviews to gauge a tenant’s suitability and interest in the property.
- Open Houses: Host open houses to meet multiple applicants at once and observe their behavior and interactions.
Conducting In-Depth Screening
Once you have a pool of pre-screened applicants, it’s time to conduct a more thorough screening. Follow these steps methodically, and you’ll reach a decision you can be confident in without wasting time:
Reviewing Application Forms
Carefully review each application form to verify the information provided. Look for:
- Consistency and accuracy in employment and income details
- Comparable rent amounts at previous residences
- Previous landlord contact information
Checking References
Contact the references provided by the applicants. Ask specific questions about their rental history, behavior, and reliability. This can reveal important information that may not be evident from the application form alone.
Conducting Credit Checks
Credit checks offer insight into a tenant’s financial responsibility. Use reputable credit reporting agencies to obtain detailed credit reports. Look for:
- High credit scores and minimal late payments.
- Low debt-to-income ratios.
- Evidence of responsible financial management.
Running Background Checks
Background checks help landlords identify any criminal history or other issues that could affect the safety and security of the rental property. Employ trusted background check services to obtain comprehensive reports.
Abiding by the Fair Housing Act and Other Relevant Regulation
One of the most important steps to take throughout the screening process is to abide by the Fair Housing Act and any relevant laws that pertain to your area. This keeps you compliant and prevents discrimination in screening. It’s always advisable to reach out to a legal professional for accurate details on how to abide by these laws and set up a fair screening process.
Making the Decision
After completing the screening process, compare the applicants based on the established criteria. Select the tenant who best meets the criteria and seems likely to be responsible and reliable. Remember to comply with fair housing laws and avoid discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, national origin, familial status, or disability, consulting a legal professional when in doubt.
Communicating with Applicants
Once you’ve made your decision, promptly inform the chosen tenant and finalize the lease agreement. Notify the other applicants respectfully, keeping a positive relationship for potential future rentals.
Signing the Lease Agreement
Check that your lease agreement is clear and comprehensive, outlining all terms and conditions. Discuss the agreement with the tenant and address any questions or concerns before signing.
Ongoing Tenant Relations
Maintaining a positive relationship with your tenants contributes to a successful rental experience and is an art all in its own. Here are some general tips you should follow and examples of tools that can help:
- Establish clear communication channels and be responsive to tenant inquiries. This can be set up easily through a tenant communication portal.
- Conduct regular property inspections to address maintenance issues promptly. A mobile inspection app can make check-ups faster and more transparent.
- Encourage tenants to report problems as soon as they see them, so you can act quickly and prevent issues from getting out of hand. This can be done through a portal or mobile app (like the ones discussed above) or through services such as a maintenance contact center.
Handling Issues with Tenants
Despite thorough screening, issues may arise. Here are steps for addressing common problems:
- Late Payments: Communicate with tenants to understand the reason for late payments and work together to find a solution. Consider setting up a payment plan if necessary.
- Property Damage: Assess the damage and determine whether it falls within normal wear and tear or requires repair. Discuss the issue with the tenant and agree on a course of action.
- Noise Complaints: Address noise complaints promptly and fairly, ensuring that tenants understand community rules regarding noise levels.
Use the Right Tools to Find the Right Tenants
Tenant screening for landlords is a critical process that can significantly impact the success of rental properties. Establishing clear screening criteria, advertising effectively, pre-screening applicants, conducting in-depth screening, making informed decisions, and maintaining positive tenant relations are all pieces of the puzzle, but that work can take up a lot of your time and energy without tools built for the job.
Buildium’s tenant screening software can do the heavy lifting and comes connected with all the other tools you’ll need for managing your property. You can give the software a try with a free, 14-day trial or a guided demo and set yourself with an easy way to manage renters.
Read more on Leasing
